Hmm...we could break the fanfic one into sub categories. Funniest fanfic, best first fanfic (after all, is it fair to judge someone's first attempt against a writer who has written a lot more? One would hope that the more you do something, the better you get.
), Best use of music in a fanfic (I'd have to pick PT for this one. From "Under the Sea" to "Somewhere over the rainbow"....all are used to better enhance the story), favorite scene from a fanfic....I could go on, but I'll stop there.
Parrish